politics is A Plea for Public Property

Written by Roderick Long
Read by Stephanie Murphy
Edited by Nick Ford

Online article: http://radgeek.com/gt/2011/10/Markets...

Also available here: http://c4ss.org/content/14721

Excerpt:

"For many libertarians, the most important argument for private property is what Garret Hardin has labeled “the tragedy of the commons” (though the basic idea goes back to Aristotle). Most resources are rivalrous—that is to say, the use of the resource by one person diminishes the amount, or the value, of that resource for others. If a rivalrous resource is also public property, meaning that no member of the public may be excluded from its use, there will be no incentive to conserve or improve the resource (why bother to sow what others may freely reap?); on the contrary, the resource will be overused and swiftly exhausted, since the inability to exclude other users makes it risky to defer consumption (why bother to save what others may freely spend?). Hence private property is needed in order to prevent depletion of resources.

...

It might be argued that this the-more-the-merrier effect occurs only with goods that are wholly or largely nonphysical, but could never apply to more concrete resources like land. As Carol Rose and David Schmidtz have shown, [4] however, although any physical resource is finite and so inevitably has some tragedy-of-the-commons aspects, many resources have “comedy-of-the-commons” aspects as well, and in some cases the latter may outweigh the former, thus making public property more efficient than private property.

For instance (to adapt one of Carol Rose’s examples), suppose that a public fair is a comedy-of-the-commons good; the more people who participate, the better (within certain limits, at any rate). Imagine two such fairs, one held on private property and the other on public. The private owner has an incentive to exclude all participants who do not pay him a certain fee; thus the fair is deprived of all the participants who cannot afford the fee. (I am assuming that the purpose of the fair is primarily social rather than commercial, so that impecunious participants would bring as much value to the fair as wealthy ones.) The fair held on public property will thus be more successful than the one held on private property.

Yet, it may be objected, so long as a comedy-of-the-commons good still has some rivalrous, tragedy-of-the-commons aspects, it will be depleted, and thus the comedy-of-the-commons benefits will be lost anyway. But this assumes that privatization is the only way to prevent overuse. In fact, however, most societies throughout history have had common areas whose users were successfully restrained by social mores, peer pressure, and the like."

Bitcoin tips welcome:

1N1pF6fLKAGg4nH7XuqYQbKYXNxCnHBWLB

politics is A Plea for Public Property
10 Likes	10 Dislikes
236 views views	2.23K followers
News & Politics	Upload TimePublished on 18 Sep 2014

Related keywords

anarchism history,tragedy of the commons solutions,anarchism in tagalog,anarchism beliefs,public property records ny state,activism in a sentence,carol rose aclu,tragedy of the commons examples,carol rosenberg miami herald,carol rosenblatt,public property records nyc,tragedy of the commons español,public property lines,activism books,politics watchdog,carol rossetti español,tragedy of the commons summary,politics quiz,carol rose clothing,tragedy of the commons quizlet,anarchism ideology,tragedy of the commons pdf,garrett hardin tragik der allmende,anarchism ideology definition,public property tax records,politicspa,garrett hardin tragedy of the commons pdf,anarchism explanation,politics of dancing,politics definition,carol rosenblum,public property rights,garrett hardin 1974,politics and war,garrett hardins,activism hashtags,politics synonym,politics and prose,anarchism in philippines,tragedy of the commons hardin,carol rossen,activism in the social media age,tragedy of the commons definition,anarchism poster,tragedy of the commons game theory,tragedy of the commons economics,anarchism origin,politics and the english language,carol rosenberg twitter,garrett hardin theory,anarchism slideshare,politics today,activism defense,politics and prose events,carol rossetti mujeres,activism definition,activism near me,activist posters,activism jobs,carol rossetti mujeres pdf,tragedy of the commons environmental science,carol rossen actress,carol rosenthal,activism examples,tragedy of the commons activity,politics for dummies,tragedy of the commons lab,tragedy of the commons simulation,carol rosenberg,activism vs advocacy,politics1,carroll rosenbloom,carol rose black,garrett leight hardings,john locke author,public property c#,anarchism philosophy,politics can be defined as,garrett hardings,tragedy of the commons meaning,public property records ny,public property records,public property map,garrett hardin quotes,public property near me,anarchism characteristics,public property records nj,activism topics,carol rose ropa,carlo rossetti zapatos,activism quotes,activism art,activism activities,tragedy of the commons ap human geography,anarchism meaning,politics news,tragedy of the commons game,anarchism meaning and example,public property auction,anarchism advantages,garrett hardin tragedy of the commons,activism shirts,carol rossetti,activism synonym,public property records morris county nj,anarchism acrostic poem,author herbert spencer,garrett hardin society,activism stickers,property (quotation subject),public property vs private property,politics and prose bookstore,tragedy of the commons essay,public property management companies,anarchism government,garrett hardin 1968,public property is land or goods,garrett hardin,tragedy of the commons apes,carol rosegg,tragedy of the commons article,anarchism country,public property tax records nj,politics podcast,public property definition,public property ipa,politics of love,anarchism examples,garrett hardin in his article lifeboat ethics argues that,garrett hardin wiki,public property search,carol's rose garden,anarchism ppt,politics shoes,activism meaning,activism songs,